Verified Supplement Data Primary-sourced

Meal Replacement Shake Guides

By Erin Rose · Updated · Methodology

A shake that replaces a meal needs more than protein. We read each label for calories, fiber, vitamins and minerals, check the testing lists, and price a shake at Amazon's price today.

1. Our pick

Huel Black Edition Vegan Protein Powder (Vanilla, 17 servings)

Huel Black Edition Vegan Protein Powder (Vanilla, 17 servings)

Calories
400 a servingTied for the most
Protein
40 gThe most of the five
Fiber
6 g27 vitamins and minerals
A meal
$2.8217 servings

Why we pick it It is a vegan powder that carries the most protein of the five and a full meal's worth of calories. You mix it with water or milk.

What you give up It costs more a meal than Orgain Nutritional Shake, and you mix it yourself.

See the five shakes we compared for this pick.

Guides

QuestionWhat the guide compares
What is the best meal replacement shake overall?five top shakes on calories, protein, fiber and cost a meal
What is the best whey-based meal replacement shake?four shakes on calories, fiber, testing list and cost a shake
What is the best meal replacement shake for losing weight?five shakes on calories, protein and fiber for a lighter meal
What is the best vegan plant-based meal replacement shake?five shakes on what each label says about vegan, plus calories and cost a meal
What is the best keto or low-carb meal replacement shake?four shakes with net carbs as each maker states them
What is the healthiest meal replacement shake made with natural whole food ingredients?four shakes on label facts, with no health claims

Related