What Is the Best Meal Replacement Shake for Losing Weight?
The best meal replacement shake for losing weight is Ka'Chava, a 240-calorie meal with 25 g of protein and 6 g of fiber. We compared five shakes at Amazon prices checked November 20, 2026.
By Erin Rose Updated November 18, 2026 How we score
1. Our pick
- Calories
- 240 a servingA meal, not a snack
- Protein
- 25 g10.4 g per 100 calories
- Fiber
- 6 gThe most for its calories of the five
- A meal
- $4.5315 servings
Why we pick it It keeps a meal near 240 calories and still carries protein and fiber, along with iron 25%, calcium 30%, vitamin D 25% of daily value. It is the only one of the five on a testing list, and you stir it into water or milk.
What you give up It costs the most a meal of the five, and you mix it yourself.
Four other shakes to weigh against the pick
2. Fewest calories
- Calories
- 180 a serving
- A meal
- $3.39
OWYN has the fewest calories of the five, 180, in a dairy-free bottle that needs no mixing. It also gives the most protein for those calories. A bottle this size is a light meal, so you can add fruit or oats when you want more food.
3. Most protein
- Calories
- 400 a serving
- A meal
- $2.82
Huel Black Edition has the most protein of the five, 40 g, in a 400-calorie serving. That is a large meal, so it suits a day when one shake replaces your biggest meal. The vegan powder mixes with water or a plant milk.
4. Same calories, less protein
- Calories
- 240 a serving
- A meal
- $2.75
Orgain Nutritional Shake matches the pick at 240 calories but gives less protein and less fiber, and it costs less a meal. It is a vegan carton you can drink straight from the fridge, which helps when you cannot mix a powder.
5. Ready to drink, bigger meal
- Calories
- 400 a serving
- A meal
- $4.00
Soylent Complete Meal is a bottle you open and drink, with 400 calories, the same as Huel, and half the fiber the pick gives. It comes in a 12 pack, so it suits a routine where you want the same ready meal every day.
Five shakes for losing weight, side by side
The pick costs $4.53 a meal. Orgain Nutritional Shake costs $2.75, with less protein and fiber. OWYN costs $3.39 and is a smaller meal. Huel Black Edition costs $2.82 and is a bigger meal. Soylent Complete Meal costs $4.00 with less fiber.
OWYN, Huel Black Edition, Orgain Nutritional Shake and Soylent Complete Meal are not on a testing list.
| Shake | Calories | Protein | Fiber | Vitamins and minerals | Testing list | Price a meal | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal Shake (Chocolate, 2 lb, 15 servings)Our pick | 240 | 25 g | 6 g | 85+ superfoods and nutrients; iron 25%, calcium 30%, vitamin D 25% of daily value | NSF Certified for Sport | $4.53$67.99 for 15 | See on Amazon |
| OWYN 26g High Protein Shake (Chocolate, 12 fl oz, 12 Pack) | 180 | 26 g | 3 g | 23 vitamins and minerals | No listing found | $3.39$40.73 for 12 | See on Amazon |
| Orgain Organic Nutritional Vegan Shake (Chocolate, 11 oz, 12 Pack) | 240 | 16 g | 2 g | 22 vitamins and minerals | No listing found | $2.75$32.99 for 12 | See on Amazon |
| Huel Black Edition Vegan Protein Powder (Vanilla, 17 servings) | 400 | 40 g | 6 g | 27 vitamins and minerals | No listing found | $2.82$47.99 for 17 | See on Amazon |
| Soylent Complete Meal Shake (Creamy Chocolate, 14 oz, 12 Pack) | 400 | 20 g | 3 g | 28 vitamins and minerals | No listing found | $4.00$48.00 for 12 | See on Amazon |
How we read calories, protein and fiber
The first number we read is the calories in one meal. Our five run from 180 to 400 a serving, and Ka'Chava sits at the light end of a full meal.
Protein and fiber come next, counted against the calories. For every 100 calories, OWYN gives 14.4 g of protein, Ka'Chava gives 10.4 g of protein, Huel Black Edition gives 10.0 g of protein, Orgain Nutritional Shake gives 6.7 g of protein, Soylent Complete Meal gives 5.0 g of protein. For fiber the order is Ka'Chava at 2.5 g, OWYN at 1.7 g, Huel Black Edition at 1.5 g, Orgain Nutritional Shake at 0.8 g, Soylent Complete Meal at 0.8 g.
One shake a day for a week costs $31.71 with Ka'Chava and $19.25 with Orgain Nutritional Shake. Replace a second meal and both numbers double.
Looking for something narrower?
For the shake with the most protein and calories overall, see the best meal replacement shake overall. For plant-based only, see the best vegan meal replacement shake. For shakes judged on protein alone, see the best protein shakes. All our shake guides are in the meal replacement shake guides.
Questions about meal replacement shakes
How many calories should a meal replacement shake have?
Our five range from 180 to 400 calories a serving. Pick the size of meal you want to replace, and check that the shake still carries protein, fiber and vitamins.
Why not pick the shake with the fewest calories?
OWYN has the fewest, but it is a small meal. A meal replacement should still carry fiber and a range of vitamins and minerals, so we ranked on those as well as calories.
Which of these shakes is on a testing list?
Only Ka'Chava. NSF Certified for Sport tests for banned substances and checks the label, and its list, copied October 1, 2026, holds "Ka'Chava Superfood, Chocolate". The other four are not on that list.
How we picked
We started from the shakes shoppers compare for losing weight and kept those with a buyable Amazon listing. We ranked on calories for one meal, then protein and fiber for those calories, then whether a testing list names the shake, then cost a meal. Label values come from the maker or a store label page, as listed below. Amazon prices were read November 20, 2026. The NSF list copy is from October 1, 2026.
Sources
- Amazon listings of the products above, prices read November 20, 2026.
- Labels: Ka'Chava at kachava.com; OWYN at eatthismuch.com; Huel Black Edition at huel.com; Orgain Nutritional Shake at orgain.com; Soylent Complete Meal at cdn.shopify.com.
- Testing list: NSF Certified for Sport, product name "Ka'Chava Superfood, Chocolate" (listing 1568674), list dated October 1, 2026.




