Verified Supplement Data

Are Quest, Barebells and RXBAR Protein Bars as Clean as They Claim?

Our pick is RXBAR: its label starts with dates, egg whites and cashews and lists no sugar alcohol or artificial sweetener, at $2.12 a bar. Quest and Barebells print protein and sugar numbers that hold but use erythritol, sucralose and maltitol. We read three labels and priced them November 20, 2026.

By Erin Rose Updated November 2026 How we score

1. Our pick

RXBAR (Chocolate Sea Salt, 12 bars)

RXBAR (Chocolate Sea Salt, 12 bars)

Check price on Amazon Price checked Nov 20
Protein
12 g200 calories
Sugar
14 g0 g added
Sweeteners
No sugar alcohol or artificial sweetenerNone added; the sugar is from dates
Cost
$25.48 for 12 barsAmazon’s price

Why we pick it Its label has no sugar alcohol and no artificial sweetener. A bar passes our clean test when its label lists no sugar alcohol (erythritol, maltitol, sorbitol or xylitol) and no artificial sweetener (sucralose, acesulfame K or aspartame). We pick the bar of the three brands that passes and, if more than one does, the one with the most protein. The trade: it has less protein than Quest and Barebells.

Brand by brand: what the box says and what the label shows

2. Quest: numbers hold, sweeteners fail the test

The Amazon listing says “21g protein, 4g net carbs and 1g sugar” and no added sugars. The label agrees with those numbers. What the box does not say: it is sweetened with erythritol, stevia and sucralose. That fails our clean test on a sugar alcohol (erythritol) and an artificial sweetener (sucralose) (6 g of sugar alcohol a bar).

Quest Protein Bar (Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, 12 bars)

Quest Protein Bar (Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, 12 bars)

Check price on Amazon

3. Barebells: numbers hold, sweeteners fail the test

The Amazon listing says “20 grams of protein, 1g total sugars” and free from added sugars, GMO free and palm oil free. The label agrees with those numbers. The box leaves out the sweeteners: it uses maltitol and sucralose. Our test marks it down for a sugar alcohol (maltitol) and an artificial sweetener (sucralose) (5 g of sugar alcohol a bar). We read the Cookies & Cream label; the Caramel Cashew label lists the same two sweeteners.

Barebells Protein Bar (Classics variety pack, 12 bars)

Barebells Protein Bar (Classics variety pack, 12 bars)

Check price on Amazon

4. More protein, same clean test: RISE

If 12 g is too little, RISE keeps the clean label with 16 g; RXBAR stays our pick at $2.12 a bar. RISE Almond Honey has 16 g of sugar (15 g added) and is sweetened with honey, so it passes the same test. It costs $2.23 a bar.

Rise Whey Almond Honey (12 bars)

Rise Whey Almond Honey (12 bars)

Check price on Amazon

The three brands and cleaner bars, side by side

Each row is one bar Amazon sold on November 20, 2026. Our pick comes first.

Cost a bar is Amazon’s price divided by the bars in the box. Labels read October 18, 2026. The clean test is: no sugar alcohol and no artificial sweetener on the label.
Bar and size soldProtein and sugarSweeteners on the labelClean testCost a barBuy
RXBAROur pickChocolate Sea Salt, 12 bars, $25.48
12 g protein, 14 g sugarNone added; the sugar is from datesPasses$2.12 See on Amazon
Quest Protein BarChocolate Chip Cookie Dough, 12 bars, $28.00
21 g protein, 1 g sugarErythritol, stevia and sucraloseFails: a sugar alcohol (erythritol) and an artificial sweetener (sucralose)$2.33 See on Amazon
Barebells Protein BarClassics variety pack, 12 bars, $31.99
20 g protein, 1 g sugarMaltitol and sucraloseFails: a sugar alcohol (maltitol) and an artificial sweetener (sucralose)$2.67 See on Amazon
Rise Whey Almond HoneyAlmond Honey, 12 bars, $26.78
16 g protein, 16 g sugarHoneyPasses$2.23 See on Amazon

What testing lists and the public record show

We looked up all three brands on NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Choice and Informed Sport (read October 18, 2026) and none of them has a bar on those lists.

The Clean Label Project’s May 27, 2025 bar study tested 165 top-selling bars from 50 brands, more than 20,000 lab tests: every bar had a detectable heavy metal, and 22% were over California's Prop 65 lead limit. Industry groups disputed the method. Quest, Barebells and RXBAR bars are all in the tested set. The page publishes no score for any one bar and none of the three is certified, so there is no per-bar result to quote.

Quest. A class action filed September 23, 2026 (Colby v. Quest Nutrition) says Quest's “healthy” wording does not fit the erythritol in at least 45 of its products. No ruling is reported. FDA's recall database lists one Quest bar recall since 2018: an undeclared almond, in 2018. Source: case summary, FDA recall F-0051-2019.

Barebells. Barebells' own product page carries a warning that maltitol can have a laxative effect. FDA's recall database lists no Barebells bar recall since 2018. Source: Barebells product page.

RXBAR. FDA's recall database lists one RXBAR recall: undeclared peanut across 19 varieties, reported in 2019, traced to a third-party ingredient. Source: FDA recall notice.

Questions about Quest, Barebells and RXBAR

Are Quest protein bars clean?

Not by our test. Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough is sweetened with erythritol, stevia and sucralose, even though its protein and sugar numbers hold.

Are Barebells protein bars clean?

Not by our test. Barebells Classics variety pack is sweetened with maltitol and sucralose, even though its protein and sugar numbers hold.

Are RXBAR protein bars clean?

Yes, by our test. RXBAR Chocolate Sea Salt starts with dates, egg whites, cashews, almonds, chocolate and lists no sugar alcohol or artificial sweetener. The sugar in it comes from the foods in the bar.

Which of Quest, Barebells and RXBAR is the cleanest?

RXBAR Chocolate Sea Salt. It is the one of the three whose label has no sugar alcohol and no artificial sweetener. The trade: it has less protein than Quest and Barebells.

Is any of these bars on a testing list?

No. NSF, Informed Choice and Informed Sport name none of the three. That is no entry in those lists, not a finding that the bars were never tested.

How we checked

We took the main line of each brand the question names, Quest, Barebells and RXBAR. On October 18, 2026 we read each label and the wording on its listing, compared the protein and sugar the box states with the label, then listed each sweetener. We looked each brand up on three testing lists, in the Clean Label Project’s 2025 bar study and in FDA’s recall database. Prices are Amazon’s, November 20, 2026. For ranked lists see best protein bars, cleanest protein bars, highest protein bars, best low sugar protein bars and best gluten free protein bars; the protein bar database has the rest, and the protein hub has everything else.

Sources

  1. Quest label: Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough page, read October 18, 2026.
  2. Barebells label: Barebells Classics variety pack page, read October 18, 2026.
  3. RXBAR label: RXBAR Chocolate Sea Salt page, read October 18, 2026.
  4. Clean Label Project, Snack and Nutrition Bar Category Report, May 27, 2025.
  5. FDA food enforcement reports (recalls reported since 2018), searched by brand. Testing lists: the three named above, read October 18, 2026. Prices: Amazon listings, November 20, 2026.