Verified Supplement Data

Vital Proteins vs NeoCell Collagen

Buy Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides: $0.62 per 10 g of collagen, the lowest of the six products we priced on November 18, 2026. It is on NSF Certified for Sport. NeoCell's powders cost more per 10 g and none of its products is on a testing list we hold.

By Erin Rose Updated November 2026 How we score

1. Our pick

Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides (Unflavored, 14.3 oz)

Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides (Unflavored, 14.3 oz)

Check price on Amazon Price checked Nov 18
Collagen
20 gIn 4 tbsp
Cost
$0.62 per 10 g20 servings
Testing list
NSF Certified for SportRead October 1, 2026

Why we pick it Plain powder to plain powder, it costs less per 10 g than NeoCell's grass-fed powder, and NSF lists it. NSF tests a listed product for banned substances and checks the label. NeoCell's serving is 10 g, so it takes two NeoCell scoops to match one Vital Proteins serving.

How the other five compare

2. The plain powder match: NeoCell Grassfed Collagen Peptides Powder

10 g in 1 heaping scoop. The label panel prints about 20 servings; the tub holds 400 g, which at 10 g a scoop is 40, and the maker calls it a 40-day supply, so we use 40. It costs price not shown per 10 g, $0.05 more than our pick. Choose it if 10 g a day is your dose and you want a smaller daily scoop.

NeoCell Grassfed Collagen Peptides Powder (Unflavored, 14 oz)

NeoCell Grassfed Collagen Peptides Powder

Check price on Amazon

3. Vital Proteins with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C: Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides Advanced

20 g in 3 tbsp, 27 servings, with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C added. It costs $0.72 per 10 g, $0.10 more than our pick. Neither NSF list names this formula, so it reads "Not on a testing list." Choose it for the added hyaluronic acid and vitamin C.

Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides Advanced (Unflavored, 20 oz)

Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides Advanced

Check price on Amazon

4. Tablets: NeoCell Collagen + C Tablets

6 g in 6 tablets, 41 servings from 250 tablets. It costs $0.78 per 10 g and is on no testing list. Choose it if you will not drink a powder.

NeoCell Grassfed Collagen Peptides + C, 6,000 mg (250 tablets)

NeoCell Collagen + C Tablets

Check price on Amazon

5. NeoCell's hyaluronic acid pair: NeoCell Collagen Peptides + Hyaluronic Acid + C

12 g in 1 scoop, with 60 mg of hyaluronic acid and 120 mg of vitamin C per serving. It costs $0.81 per 10 g and is on no testing list. Its closest Vital Proteins match is the Advanced powder above, which costs $0.72 per 10 g.

NeoCell Collagen Peptides + Hyaluronic Acid + C Powder (Unflavored, 13.7 oz)

NeoCell Collagen Peptides + Hyaluronic Acid + C

Check price on Amazon

6. Gummies: NeoCell Collagen Peptides Gummies

The label lists 120 mg of collagen in 2 gummies, against 20 g in one Vital Proteins serving. That works out to $36.08 per 10 g. Choose them only if a gummy is the one form you will take.

NeoCell Collagen Peptides Gummies (60 gummies)

NeoCell Collagen Peptides Gummies

Check price on Amazon

Six products, side by side

Our pick comes first, then the rest from lowest cost per 10 g. NeoCell's powder, tablets and gummies list different grams, so the table prices every row by the grams of collagen in it. NeoCell's tub count for the grass-fed powder comes from its net weight.

At Amazon's price, priced November 18, 2026. Cost per 10 g is the price divided by the servings and the grams of collagen in a serving, times 10.
ProductCollagenPack priceCost per 10 gTesting listBuy
Vital Proteins Collagen PeptidesOur pick14.3 oz, 20 servings
20 g$24.99$0.62NSF Certified for Sport, listed by name, read October 1, 2026 See on Amazon
NeoCell Grassfed Collagen Peptides Powder14 oz, 40 servings (from net weight)
10 g—price not shownNot on a testing list See on Amazon
20 g$38.99$0.72Not on a testing list See on Amazon
NeoCell Collagen + C Tablets250 tablets, 41 servings
6 g—$0.78Not on a testing list See on Amazon
12 g—$0.81Not on a testing list See on Amazon
NeoCell Collagen Peptides Gummies60 gummies, 30 servings
120 mg$12.99$36.08Not on a testing list See on Amazon

Questions about NeoCell and Vital Proteins

Is NeoCell collagen worth buying?

NeoCell's grass-fed powder is a fair value: 10 g in a serving, close to our pick on cost. The rest of NeoCell's line costs more per 10 g, and we found none of it on a testing list.

Is NeoCell collagen third-party tested?

We found none of the four NeoCell products on this page on a testing list. We searched NSF Certified for Sport (read October 1, 2026) and NSF/ANSI 173 (read August 25, 2026). NeoCell's labels carry the maker's own quality claims, which are not a testing list.

Which Vital Proteins collagen is on a testing list?

The plain Collagen Peptides powder. NSF Certified for Sport lists it (listing 1792557). The Advanced formula is not on that list.

How many grams of collagen do NeoCell gummies have?

120 mg in two gummies, so you would need many servings to reach the 20 g in one Vital Proteins serving.

How we compared them

We took the Vital Proteins and NeoCell collagens shoppers ask about that Amazon sold on November 18, 2026, and used Amazon's price for each. Grams and servings come from each label, except NeoCell's grass-fed servings, which come from net weight as noted in that row. Testing lines come from the NSF Certified for Sport list read on October 1, 2026 and NSF/ANSI 173 read August 25, 2026. For more, see third-party tested collagen, Vital Proteins vs Orgain and Youtheory vs Vital Proteins. All of it starts at our collagen guides.

Sources

  1. Amazon listings of the six products above, priced November 18, 2026; grams and servings from the label on each listing, and from the maker's page for NeoCell's grass-fed powder.
  2. Testing: NSF Certified for Sport, read October 1, 2026; listing 1792557. NSF/ANSI 173, read August 25, 2026.