Verified Supplement Data

BioNatal vs Sidr and Stone Black Seed Oil: Which to Buy 2026

Buy BioNatal Ethiopian black seed oil: $38.89 for 25 teaspoons, $1.56 a teaspoon on Amazon. Its maker says an outside lab tests each harvest. Sidr & Stone posts one lab report: 2.67% thymoquinone, the compound labels count.

By Erin Rose Updated November 14, 2026 Methodology

Our pick

BioNatal Ethiopian Black Seed Oil, Liquid (4.2 fl oz)

BioNatal Ethiopian Black Seed Oil (4.2 fl oz)

Check price on Amazon Price checked Nov 20
Price on Amazon
$38.8925 teaspoons (4.2 fl oz)
Cost
$1.56 a teaspoonOne teaspoon (5 mL) a serving
Testing
Not on a testing listMaker says Eurofins tests each harvest

BioNatal’s own page says it holds a UL Solutions GMP certificate for manufacturing and packaging (September 17, 2026) and tests thymoquinone with Eurofins, an outside lab, by harvest. The bottle is glass. Sidr & Stone’s one posted report is the number you can read; BioNatal is the pick for the named lab and the plant certificate.

BioNatal and Sidr & Stone side by side

What each brand’s own page says, except the last row.
What we comparedBioNatalSidr & Stone
Seed originEthiopia. A “direct importer” of the seeds.Ethiopia. “We source exclusively from Ethiopia.”
ExtractionCold pressed. Says it tests each press machine once.Cold pressed. “No heat, no chemical solvents.”
Thymoquinone (TQ)“Highest ever TQ of 4.64%” in a 2022 sample. Not a promise for each bottle.2.67% in its first batch, August 2025.
How often testedBy harvest, not every lot.Says every batch.
LabEurofinsAnalytice, an ISO 9001-certified lab in France
Report you can openNo. Kept as internal records.Yes. Report R/25/31283, 5 August 2025.
BottleGlassUV-protected matte black glass
On a testing listNot on a testing listNot on a testing list

Which one is more open about its testing?

Sidr & Stone. It posts report R/25/31283 from Analytice, dated 5 August 2025, for its first batch. BioNatal’s page says “The Certificate of Analysis (COA) and numerical results are retained as internal quality records. Our laboratory agreements restrict their public disclosure.”

BioNatal does name its lab, Eurofins, and says it tests by harvest. It also holds a UL Solutions GMP certificate for manufacturing and packaging, which its page says “addresses our manufacturing and packaging processes, rather than guaranteeing a TQ percentage in each bottle.” That is why we pick BioNatal for the named lab and the plant certificate, not for a number you can check.

Does BioNatal have more thymoquinone?

The two figures are not the same kind of number. BioNatal’s 4.64% is a 2022 result it calls its “highest ever,” and its page adds: “Results relate to the sample tested and do not guarantee the same TQ percentage in every lot or bottle.” Sidr & Stone’s 2.67% is its first batch, from August 2025. Neither is a reading of the bottle you buy. BioNatal’s page lists a newer report on file, dated September 24, 2026, and does not post its numbers.

Which bottle protects the oil from light?

Sidr & Stone says it bottles in “UV-protected matte black glass with airtight seals.” BioNatal’s page calls its 4.2 oz bottle a glass bottle. BioNatal also says it is moving that bottle from 4.2 fl oz to 4 fl oz, and that “you may see different bottle sizes and label versions.”

Who should buy which

More: our black seed oil page and the list of black seed oil brands with lab reports.

Questions

Which is better, BioNatal or Sidr and Stone black seed oil?

Buy BioNatal. Its page says a named outside lab, Eurofins, tests each harvest for thymoquinone, and that it holds a UL Solutions GMP certificate for manufacturing and packaging. Sidr & Stone is the one that posts a report you can open, for its first batch.

Is BioNatal black seed oil third-party tested?

BioNatal says so. Its analysis page says it tests through Eurofins, by harvest rather than every lot, and that the reports are internal records its lab agreements keep private. No testing list names it.

Is Sidr and Stone black seed oil third-party tested?

Sidr & Stone posts a report from Analytice, a French lab, dated 5 August 2025 (report R/25/31283). It covers the first batch only. No testing list names Sidr & Stone.

Which has more thymoquinone?

The two figures measure different things. BioNatal’s 4.64% is a 2022 result it calls its highest, and its page says a result does not guarantee the same percent in every bottle. Sidr & Stone’s figure is one batch of its oil.

Are BioNatal and Sidr and Stone black seed oil cold pressed?

Both say so. Sidr & Stone writes “no heat, no chemical solvents.” BioNatal says it tests its cold press once on each press machine.

Sources

  1. BioNatal: Analysis and Certificates (thymoquinone testing, Eurofins, GMP certificate, bottle sizes).
  2. Sidr & Stone: Quality Assurance (Analytice report R/25/31283, cold pressing, bottle).