Verified Supplement Data

What Is the Best Beta Carotene Supplement (and Why Do Smokers Avoid It)?

Our pick is Swanson Beta Carotene: 300 softgels in one bottle at $0.05 a day. We compared 4 beta carotene products on November 20, 2026. NIH’s warning for smokers is below the table.

By Erin Rose Updated November 2026 How we score

1. Our pick, beta carotene

Swanson Beta Carotene

Swanson Beta Carotene (300 softgels)

Check price on Amazon Price checked Nov 20
Strength a softgel
25,000 IU7,500 mcg of vitamin A as beta carotene
Softgels
300One a day lasts the whole bottle
Cost
$0.05 a day$15.67 for the bottle

Why we pick it Three of the four products here are the same strength, so the choice is the bottle. Swanson’s listing prints the strength per softgel in plain words, and one bottle runs 300 days.

Products at or below the pick’s cost a day:

  • Horbaach Beta Carotene costs $0.05 a day, the same, at the same strength. Swanson is still the pick because one bottle holds 300 softgels, a 300-day supply. Choose Horbaach for the lowest cost a day.
  • Puritan's Pride Beta Carotene costs $0.05 a day, the same, at the same strength. Swanson is still the pick because one bottle holds 300 softgels, a 300-day supply. Choose Puritan's for a small first bottle at about the same cost a day.

Four beta carotene supplements side by side

One row per product, our pick first. Each is one softgel a day.

Strength and softgel count are quoted from each Amazon listing. Cost a day is Amazon’s price divided by the softgels in the bottle.
ProductStrength a softgelSoftgelsCost a dayBuy
25,000 IU 300 $0.05 Check price on Amazon
25,000 IU 400 $0.05 Check price on Amazon
25,000 IU 100 $0.05 Check price on Amazon
Not printed in the listing 90 $0.41 Check price on Amazon

2. The biggest bottle: Horbaach Beta Carotene

Horbaach Beta Carotene 25,000 IU (400 softgels)

Horbaach Beta Carotene

Strength a softgel
Same as the pick
Softgels
400
Cost
$0.05 a day$18.99 for the bottle

It has the most softgels of the four, 100 more than our pick, at the same strength. Choose it when you want the longest supply.

3. The lowest price for one bottle: Puritan's Pride Beta Carotene

Puritan's Pride Beta Carotene 25,000 IU (100 softgels)

Puritan's Pride Beta Carotene

Strength a softgel
Same as the pick
Softgels
100
Cost
$5.21 a bottle$0.05 a day

It is the lowest price for one bottle of the four, at the same strength. Choose it for a small first buy.

Why smokers avoid beta carotene

The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements describes two large trials in its vitamin A fact sheet:

“The ATBC trial found that supplementation with a large amount of beta-carotene (20 mg/day), with or without 50 mg/day vitamin E, for 5–8 years increased the risk of lung cancer and mortality (mainly from lung cancer and ischemic heart disease) in male smokers.”

“The CARET trial also showed that supplementation with a large amount of beta-carotene (30 mg/day) plus 7,500 mcg RAE (25,000 IU)/day retinyl palmitate for 4–8 years in current and former smokers as well as some men occupationally exposed to asbestos increased the risk of lung cancer and death from lung cancer.”

NIH sums it up this way: “The CARET and ATBC study results suggest that large supplemental doses of beta-carotene with or without retinyl palmitate have detrimental effects in current or former smokers and workers exposed to asbestos.”

Brands people ask about that have no button here

NOW sells a beta carotene softgel at the same strength as our pick, 180 to a bottle. Solgar has no plain beta carotene softgel on Amazon. Life Extension has no plain beta carotene softgel on Amazon.

How we compared

We compared four beta carotene softgels on the strength and count each Amazon listing prints, and on Amazon cost a day, read November 20, 2026. One softgel a day is the listing’s own direction. For the retinol form of vitamin A, see the vitamin A dosage guide.

Questions about beta carotene

What is the best beta carotene supplement?

Swanson Beta Carotene is our pick. Its bottle holds 300 softgels, one a day.

Why do smokers avoid beta carotene supplements?

NIH’s Office of Dietary Supplements says the ATBC and CARET trials found a higher risk of lung cancer in smokers who took large amounts of beta carotene. The trial details are quoted above.

Is beta carotene the same as vitamin A?

Beta carotene is a plant form that the body can turn into vitamin A. NIH counts 2 mcg of supplemental beta carotene as 1 mcg of vitamin A (RAE). For retinol and its limit, see the vitamin A dosage guide.

More on vitamin A

For vitamins A, D, E and K in one product, read the best ADEK supplement. For one vitamin A and D product, read the best vitamin A and D supplement. See all of vitamin A.

Sources

  1. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, Vitamin A and Carotenoids: Health Professional Fact Sheet, read November 18, 2026.
  2. Amazon listings of the four products above, prices read November 20, 2026.