What Are the Best Probiotic Gummies?
Garden of Life Dr. Formulated 10 Billion Probiotic Gummies is our pick: 10 billion CFU in 2 gummies, under 1 g of sugar and none added, and on NSF/ANSI 173’s list. $1.54 a day. Want the lowest cost? Amazon Basics Prebiotic & Probiotic is $0.34 a day for 2 billion CFU.
By Erin Rose Updated November 2026 How we score
1. Our pick
Garden of Life Dr. Formulated 10 Billion CFU Probiotic Gummies Orange Dream
- CFU
- 10 billion per 2 gummiesLabel: “Total Probiotic Cultures 10 Billion CFU”
- Per 10 billion CFU
- $1.54$37.04 for 24 servings
- Cost
- $1.54 a day24 servings of 2 gummies
Why we pick it It has the most CFU of the five gummies, 10 billion in 2 gummies, and the least sugar: Total Sugars <1 g; Includes 0g Added Sugars 0%. NSF/ANSI 173 lists it. The label says “At expiration date under recommended storage conditions.” Strains printed: Bacillus subtilis DE111 and Bacillus coagulans SNZ 1969. $1.54 a day, $37.04 for 24 servings.
How do probiotic gummies compare on CFU, sugar and cost?
Among the five gummies, cost per 10 billion CFU runs from $1.54 to $5.15, which is 3.3 times apart. Cost a day runs from $0.34 to $1.54. Each serving is 2 gummies.
A CFU count holds at one point in a pack’s life, and labels differ on which point. Three of the five labels say when the count applies. For comparison, the lowest cost per 10 billion CFU among capsules on a testing list is $0.20, against $1.54 to $5.15 for these gummies (capsule list).
More gummies to compare
2. Want the lowest cost? Amazon Basics Prebiotic & Probiotic Gummies 2 Billion CFU Blue Raspberry
Not on a testing list. Each serving is 2 gummies and the pack holds 25 servings. A day costs $0.34; 30 days cost $10.24. Ten billion CFU costs $1.71. Label: “Bacillus coagulans 20 mg, 2 Billion CFU”. Footnote: “Colony Forming Units at end of shelf life.” Sugar as printed: Total Sugars 1 g; Includes 1 g Added Sugars.
Amazon Basics Prebiotic & Probiotic Gummies 2 Billion CFU Blue Raspberry
$0.34 a day · $1.71 per 10 billion CFU
3. Culturelle in gummy form: Culturelle Daily Probiotic Gummies
Not on a testing list. Each serving is 2 gummies and the pack holds 26 servings. A day costs $0.54; 30 days cost $16.14. Ten billion CFU costs $2.69. Label: “A Proprietary Probiotic Blend 10.5 mg; Total Cultures 2 Billion CFUs”. Sugar as printed: Total Sugars 1 g; Incl. 1g Added Sugars 2%.
Culturelle Daily Probiotic Gummies
$0.54 a day · $2.69 per 10 billion CFU
4. Nature Made's gummy: Nature Made Probiotic + Prebiotic Fiber Gummies Mixed Berry
Not on a testing list. Each serving is 2 gummies and the pack holds 25 servings. A day costs $0.64; 30 days cost $19.19. Ten billion CFU costs $3.20. Label: “LactoSpore 2 Billion CFU 15 mg (Bacillus coagulans MTCC 5856)”. Footnote: “Formulated to provide at least 2 billion live cells per serving if continuously stored in a cool, dry place at or below 75F (23C) and consumed prior to expiration date.” Sugar as printed: Total Sugars 1 g.
Nature Made Probiotic + Prebiotic Fiber Gummies Mixed Berry
$0.64 a day · $3.20 per 10 billion CFU
5. OLLY in a 50 count: OLLY Probiotic Gummies Tropical Mango 1 Billion CFU
On NSF’s list as “PROBIOTIC TROPICAL MANGO” (2 gummies). Each serving is 2 gummies and the pack holds 25 servings. A day costs $0.51; 30 days cost $15.44. Ten billion CFU costs $5.15. Label: “Probiotic 1 Billion CFU 10 mg, Bacillus subtilis DE111”. Sugar as printed: Total Sugars 3 g; Includes 3 g Added Sugars 6%.
OLLY Probiotic Gummies Tropical Mango 1 Billion CFU
$0.51 a day · $5.15 per 10 billion CFU
All five probiotic gummies
The two with a testing list entry come first, then the rest. Within each group, rows start at the lowest cost per 10 billion CFU and go up.
| Product | CFU as the label prints it | Sugar a serving | Cost a day | Per 10 billion CFU | Testing list | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Garden of Life Dr. Formulated 10 Billion CFU Probiotic Gummies Orange DreamOur pick2 gummies a serving · 24 servings | “Total Probiotic Cultures 10 Billion CFU”. “At expiration date under recommended storage conditions.” | Total Sugars <1 g; Includes 0g Added Sugars 0% | $1.54 | $1.54 | On NSF’s list as “Dr. Formulated 10 Billion Probiotic Gummy” (2 gummies). The list does not say which flavor or pack size | See on Amazon |
OLLY Probiotic Gummies Tropical Mango 1 Billion CFU2 gummies a serving · 25 servings | “Probiotic 1 Billion CFU 10 mg, Bacillus subtilis DE111”. | Total Sugars 3 g; Includes 3 g Added Sugars 6% | $0.51 | $5.15 | On NSF’s list as “PROBIOTIC TROPICAL MANGO” (2 gummies) | See on Amazon |
Amazon Basics Prebiotic & Probiotic Gummies 2 Billion CFU Blue Raspberry2 gummies a serving · 25 servings | “Bacillus coagulans 20 mg, 2 Billion CFU”. “Colony Forming Units at end of shelf life.” | Total Sugars 1 g; Includes 1 g Added Sugars | $0.34 | $1.71 | Not on a testing list | See on Amazon |
Culturelle Daily Probiotic Gummies2 gummies a serving · 26 servings | “A Proprietary Probiotic Blend 10.5 mg; Total Cultures 2 Billion CFUs”. | Total Sugars 1 g; Incl. 1g Added Sugars 2% | $0.54 | $2.69 | Not on a testing list | See on Amazon |
Nature Made Probiotic + Prebiotic Fiber Gummies Mixed Berry2 gummies a serving · 25 servings | “LactoSpore 2 Billion CFU 15 mg (Bacillus coagulans MTCC 5856)”. “Formulated to provide at least 2 billion live cells per serving if continuously stored in a cool, dry place at or below 75F (23C) and consumed prior to expiration date.” | Total Sugars 1 g | $0.64 | $3.20 | Not on a testing list | See on Amazon |
Questions about probiotic gummy labels and cost
How is cost per 10 billion CFU worked out?
Divide the Amazon price by the servings in the pack to get the price of one serving, then divide that by the serving’s CFU in tens of billions. For Garden of Life Dr. Formulated 10 Billion CFU Probiotic Gummies Orange Dream: $37.04 over 24 servings is $1.54 a serving, and 10 billion CFU is 1 units of 10 billion, so each 10 billion CFU costs $1.54.
When does the CFU count on a label apply?
NIH Office of Dietary Supplements explains it this way: “Some products list the number of CFUs at the time of manufacture whereas others list the number through the expiration date or use-by date.” Three of the five labels here say when the count applies.
Which testing lists did we read?
We searched NSF/ANSI 173 and NSF Certified for Sport on November 12, 2026, and USP Verified on November 11, 2026. A product counts as listed when a listing carries its name.
Where do the sugar and serving figures come from?
From the Supplement Facts panel of each linked pack, read November 12, 2026. The table quotes the panel’s own sugar lines.
How we compared them
We copied each pack’s serving, CFU and sugar lines from its label, worked out both costs from the price, then looked up every product on the three testing lists.
Sources
- Supplement Facts panels of the five linked packs (November 12, 2026). Pack prices as of November 20, 2026.
- Testing lists searched: NSF/ANSI 173 and NSF Certified for Sport (November 12, 2026); USP Verified (November 11, 2026).
- Probiotics: Fact Sheet for Consumers, NIH Office of Dietary Supplements; see the part on how CFU counts are listed.