Centrum vs One A Day Multivitamin
Buy Centrum Silver: Centrum Silver Women 50+ and Centrum Silver Men 50+ are on NSF’s testing list, and the One A Day 50+ multivitamins are not. We compared two matching pairs, women 50+ and men 50+, priced November 20, 2026.
By Erin Rose Updated November 2026 How we score
1. Our pick
Centrum Silver Women 50+ Multivitamin Tablets (200 count)
- Takes a day
- 1 tablet200 servings in the pack
- Cost
- $0.096 a day$19.12 for the pack
- Testing list
- NSF/ANSI 173Contents match the label; read August 25, 2026
Why we pick it RDA is the daily amount the NIH sets for most adults. NSF/ANSI 173 lists “Centrum Silver Women 50+ Tablets.” It gives the adult RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate. Nothing is over an NIH upper limit. Centrum Silver Men 50+ is listed the same way, and it costs the same a day.
Both One A Day 50+ multivitamins cost $0.090 a day, against $0.096 for each Centrum Silver, but neither is on a testing list.
The matching pairs
2. Women 50+, the One A Day: One A Day Women's 50+
One A Day Women's 50+ takes 1 tablet a day. The pack has 200 servings. It gives the adult RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate. Nothing is over an NIH upper limit. No testing list we hold names it. It costs $0.090 a day. The label record we read is NIH 337448.
One A Day Women's 50+
Check price on Amazon3. Men 50+, the One A Day: One A Day Men's 50+
One A Day Men's 50+ takes 1 tablet a day. The pack has 200 servings. No testing list we hold names it. It costs $0.090 a day. We print no label amounts for this one.
One A Day Men's 50+
Check price on Amazon4. Men 50+, the Centrum: Centrum Silver Men 50+
Centrum Silver Men 50+ takes 1 tablet a day. The pack has 200 servings. It gives the adult RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate. Nothing is over an NIH upper limit. It is on NSF’s list (NSF/ANSI 173). It costs $0.096 a day.
Centrum Silver Men 50+
Check price on AmazonCentrum Silver and One A Day, side by side
Each Centrum Silver sits next to the One A Day made for the same age and sex. Our pick comes first, then the rest from the lowest cost a day.
| Multivitamin | Takes a day | Cost a day | Label against the adult RDA | Testing list | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Centrum Silver Women 50+Our pick200 servings | 1 tablet | $0.096 | Full RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate; under every limit | On NSF’s list (NSF/ANSI 173) | See on Amazon |
One A Day Women's 50+200 servings | 1 tablet | $0.090 | Full RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate; under every limit | Not on a testing list | See on Amazon |
One A Day Men's 50+200 servings | 1 tablet | $0.090 | Label not matched to this listing | Not on a testing list | See on Amazon |
Centrum Silver Men 50+200 servings | 1 tablet | $0.096 | Full RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate; under every limit | On NSF’s list (NSF/ANSI 173) | See on Amazon |
Questions about Centrum and One A Day
Which is better, Centrum or One A Day?
Centrum Silver, on testing: Centrum Silver Women 50+ and Centrum Silver Men 50+ are on NSF’s list and none of the One A Day multivitamins we checked is. Both women’s 50+ labels give the adult RDA of vitamin D, B12 and folate, but the amounts differ: B12 50 mcg against 25 mcg, folate 667 mcg DFE against 665 mcg DFE, niacin 14 mg against 20 mg.
Is One A Day cheaper than Centrum?
Yes, a little. Both One A Day 50+ multivitamins are 0.6 cents a day less.
Is Centrum or One A Day on a testing list?
Centrum Silver Women 50+ and Men 50+ are on NSF/ANSI 173 (read August 25, 2026). We found no One A Day multivitamin on NSF/ANSI 173 or USP Verified (read September 22, 2026); that is no entry in those lists, not a finding that they were never tested.
How we checked
We paired each Centrum Silver with the One A Day made for the same age and sex that Amazon sold on November 20, 2026. We read each label’s vitamin D, B12 and folate against the adult RDA in NIH’s label database where the Amazon listing matches the label, and looked up each name on NSF/ANSI 173 (August 25, 2026) and USP Verified (September 22, 2026). A product counts as listed only when a list prints its name. Prices are Amazon’s. For Centrum against Nature Made, see Nature Made vs Centrum; for each brand alone, Centrum checked and One A Day checked; for age picks, women over 50 and men over 50. More in our multivitamin guides.
Sources
- Labels: NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database, label ids 306026, 337448, 304930. Adult RDAs and upper limits from NIH’s fact sheets.
- Testing lists: NSF/ANSI 173 (read August 25, 2026), USP Verified (read September 22, 2026). Prices: Amazon listings, November 20, 2026.