Which Collagen Should You Buy at Costco or Walmart?
Buy Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides: each serving has 20 g of collagen, and its name is on NSF’s Certified for Sport list of tested supplements. Amazon’s search on November 13, 2026 for Kirkland, Member’s Mark, Great Value and Equate collagen returned no collagen powder under those names, so the table prices six tubs per 10 g.
By Erin Rose Updated November 2026 How we score
1. Our pick, 20 g of collagen in a serving
- Collagen
- 20 gIn 2 scoops (20 g)
- Servings
- 27In the tub
- Cost
- $0.57 per 10 g$1.14 a serving, $30.85 for 27
Why we pick it Its name is on NSF’s Certified for Sport list. A serving holds 20 g of collagen, so one tub lasts 27 days at one serving a day. Each row below is compared with it in cents per 10 g.
Is there Kirkland, Member’s Mark or Great Value collagen?
Kirkland Signature is Costco’s brand, Member’s Mark is Sam’s Club’s, and Great Value and Equate are Walmart’s. On November 13, 2026, Amazon’s search returned this for each name.
- Kirkland Signature collagen: a joint-health supplement with type II collagen, glucosamine tablets, chicken bone broth and vitamin C chewables.
- Member’s Mark collagen: one Member’s Mark joint-health supplement, plus books and tumbler skins.
- Great Value collagen: collagen powders from other brands and no Great Value product.
- Equate collagen: Equate face moisturizers and collagen powders from other brands.
NSF’s Certified for Sport list has a Vital Proteins listing named “Lemon Collagen Peptides (Costco)”. To check any tub on a shelf, divide its price by the servings in it times the grams of collagen in a serving, then multiply by 10. A lower number costs less for the same collagen.
Which one fits you?
2. Smaller serving: Sports Research Collagen Peptides
Sports Research Collagen Peptides costs 1 cents more per 10 g than Vital Proteins and 50 cents less a serving. A serving is 1 scoop, 11 g of collagen. Choose Sports Research Collagen Peptides for the smaller 11 g serving; choose Vital Proteins for the lower cost per 10 g.
Sports Research Collagen Peptides
$0.58 per 10 g · $0.64 a serving · $26.36 for 41
3. On two NSF lists: Thorne Collagen Fit
Thorne Collagen Fit costs 67 cents more per 10 g than Vital Proteins and 73 cents more a serving. It has 15 g of collagen a scoop. Name on NSF’s Certified for Sport and NSF/ANSI 173 lists. Choose Thorne Collagen Fit for its name on both NSF lists; choose Vital Proteins for the lower cost per 10 g.
Thorne Collagen Fit
$1.24 per 10 g · $1.87 a serving · $56.00 for 30
4. Lowest of the six per 10 g: Vev Multi Collagen Peptides
Vev Multi Collagen Peptides costs 14 cents less per 10 g than Vital Proteins and 68 cents less a serving. It has 10.9 g of collagen in 2 scoops. Name on the NSF/ANSI 173 list. Choose Vev Multi Collagen Peptides for the lowest cost per 10 g of the six here; choose Vital Proteins for its name on NSF’s Certified for Sport list.
Vev Multi Collagen Peptides
$0.43 per 10 g · $0.46 a serving · $18.99 for 41
5. Bovine collagen: BulkSupplements Hydrolyzed Bovine Collagen
BulkSupplements Hydrolyzed Bovine Collagen costs 14 cents less per 10 g than Vital Proteins and 67 cents less a serving. It has 11 g of collagen in 4 tsp. NSF’s Certified for Sport list has a BulkSupplements listing named “Bovine Collagen”. Choose BulkSupplements Hydrolyzed Bovine Collagen for the lower cost per 10 g; choose Vital Proteins for 20 g of collagen in a serving, 9 g more.
BulkSupplements Hydrolyzed Bovine Collagen
$0.43 per 10 g · $0.47 a serving · $21.22 for 45
6. Same serving size: Orgain Collagen Peptides
Orgain Collagen Peptides costs 3 cents less per 10 g than Vital Proteins and 5 cents less a serving. It has 20 g of collagen in 2 scoops. Choose Orgain Collagen Peptides for the lower cost per 10 g; choose Vital Proteins for its name on NSF’s Certified for Sport list.
Orgain Collagen Peptides
$0.54 per 10 g · $1.09 a serving · $23.88 for 22
Six collagen tubs, priced per 10 g
Our pick is first. The rest are sorted from the lowest cost per 10 g to the highest. NSF’s Certified for Sport, NSF/ANSI 173 and Informed Choice are three public lists of tested supplements; a name on one is shown in the Testing list column (Certified for Sport read October 1, 2026, NSF/ANSI 173 read August 25, 2026, Informed Choice read October 27, 2026).
| Product | Collagen a serving | Testing list | Cost | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Vital Proteins Collagen PeptidesOur pickUnflavored, 19.3 oz | 20 g in 2 scoops | Name on NSF’s Certified for Sport list | $0.57 per 10 g$1.14 a serving | See on Amazon |
| 11 g in 4 tsp | NSF’s Certified for Sport list has a BulkSupplements listing named “Bovine Collagen” | $0.43 per 10 g$0.47 a serving | See on Amazon | |
Vev Multi Collagen PeptidesUnflavored, 16 oz | 10.9 g in 2 scoops | Name on the NSF/ANSI 173 list | $0.43 per 10 g$0.46 a serving | See on Amazon |
Orgain Collagen PeptidesUnflavored, 1 lb | 20 g in 2 scoops | Not on a testing list | $0.54 per 10 g$1.09 a serving | See on Amazon |
Sports Research Collagen PeptidesUnflavored | 11 g in 1 scoop | Name on the Informed Choice list | $0.58 per 10 g$0.64 a serving | See on Amazon |
Thorne Collagen Fit30 servings | 15 g in 1 scoop | Name on NSF’s Certified for Sport and NSF/ANSI 173 lists | $1.24 per 10 g$1.87 a serving | See on Amazon |
Questions about collagen at Costco and Walmart
Which collagen should I buy at Costco?
Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides. Its name is on NSF’s Certified for Sport list, and that list has a Vital Proteins listing named “Lemon Collagen Peptides (Costco)”. Use the cost per 10 g in the table to check any tub on the shelf against it.
Which collagen should I buy at Walmart?
The same pick, Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides, with 20 g of collagen in a serving. Choose Vev Multi Collagen Peptides for the lowest cost per 10 g here; choose Vital Proteins for its name on NSF’s Certified for Sport list.
Is there a Kirkland, Member’s Mark or Great Value collagen powder on Amazon?
Amazon’s search on November 13, 2026 for those names returned no collagen powder from those brands. The store-brand section above says what each search returned.
How we picked
We started from three well-known collagen brands, Vital Proteins, Sports Research and Thorne, and added Vev, BulkSupplements and Orgain. Servings and grams of collagen a serving come from the product labels. The lists were read October 1, 2026 (NSF Certified for Sport), August 25, 2026 (NSF/ANSI 173) and October 27, 2026 (Informed Choice), and a name is shown only when the list has it. Amazon prices were read November 20, 2026.
Sources
- Amazon listings and label panels of the products above, prices read November 20, 2026; Amazon search results for Kirkland Signature, Member’s Mark, Great Value and Equate collagen.
- NSF Certified for Sport listings, nsfsport.com, read October 1, 2026; NSF/ANSI 173 certified products, info.nsf.org, read August 25, 2026; Informed Choice certified products, choice.wetestyoutrust.com, read October 27, 2026.
